Every Pitch Matters.

October 1, 2025
Featured image for “Every Pitch Matters.”
By: Preston Young

October is here and that means postseason baseball. The games are slower but heavier, every pitch feels like it could swing a season, and even the smallest managerial move is magnified under the postseason spotlight.

This year, the script is as classic as it gets: the Red Sox and Yankees in October. Neither team had the season they hoped for, both falling short of a division crown but the beauty of October baseball is that once you’re in, anything can happen. Here we are, a three-game Wild Card series that pits baseball’s oldest rivals against one another for the right to keep their season alive.

Game 1 set the tone. There’s nothing quite like Yankee Stadium in October, and as a Red Sox fan, there’s nothing sweeter than silencing it. The energy was electric, emotions were high, and every at-bat felt like it mattered.

What stood out most wasn’t just the win itself, but the way it unfolded. The Yankees made some head-scratching choices with their starting lineup and pinch hits, decisions that will be second-guessed all week. On the other side, the Red Sox starter eventually handed the ball to our closer, none other than former Yankee Aroldis Chapman, who slammed the door in chaotic fashion. That kind of drama is what October baseball is all about.

As much as I love this matchup, it’s hard to ignore that the Red Sox–Yankees rivalry doesn’t carry quite the same fire it once did. Baseball viewership has slipped in recent years, and younger fans haven’t experienced the same hot intensity of the early 2000s clashes.

Growing up, I missed the Bucky Dent and Aaron Boone eras, but I was old enough to experience what many consider the peak: the 2004 ALCS comeback. Down 3–0, the Red Sox stormed back to win four straight and shock the Yankees in what remains one of the greatest postseason turnarounds in sports history. That series gave us unforgettable moments: Dave Roberts’ steal in Game 4, Big Papi’s walk-offs, Schilling’s bloody sock — moments that felt larger than baseball itself.

The rivalry has cooled since then, but every October meeting still feels like a chance to spark something new.

October is a sports fan’s paradise. Football is in full midseason stride, bye weeks are beginning, and teams are showing who they really are. Saturdays belong to college football, Sundays to the NFL, and weeknights to postseason baseball. Add in the NBA and NHL gearing up for opening weeks, and you’ve got nonstop storylines in every direction. It’s the rare moment in the calendar where all the major sports collide, and as a fan, there’s nothing better than flipping between games and knowing you’re watching seasons being defined.

So here we are again. Sox versus Yankees. October baseball. Every pitch, every managerial decision, every unexpected hero has the chance to etch itself into history. The rivalry may not be as fierce as it once was, but it only takes one unforgettable moment to bring it roaring back.

Game 1 went to Boston in the Bronx, but the series is far from over. No matter what happens, one thing’s for certain: October baseball is still one of the greatest shows in sports.

Tracking: 805202-1


Share: